Motion of the Moon Supplement
This supplement is meant to aid TA's and instructors. It assumes
that the homework data is being collected with Voyager, though that
is not essential for this to be useful. It also introduces students
to Voyager and uses the Mac's large display screen to help explain
some concepts that the students can follow up on their own time
using classroom Macs. It is intended that the TA's should run
through this once as practice before trying to teach it.
As with the assignment text, this lab needs to be updated each
time it is used to accurately reflect what's in the sky.
Pre-assignment demonstration
- Before class, do the following:
- Start up Voyager.
- Set the magnitude limits such that only stars brighter than 2nd
magnitude appear.
- Set the local time to be 6 pm PDT on June 19, 1993 (be sure to type
the whole year rather than just ``93''.
- Set View From Location to be Seattle, WA.
- Center and lock on the Moon.
- Set the timestep to 6 hours.
- Be sure you're zoomed out all the way.
- During class, do the following exercises. All of them are
optional. Simply choose what you think is best.
- Introduce some of the things about Voyager, maybe showing what the
different coordinate systems look like (especially Local Horizon).
For the demo, it is easier to stick with Star Atlas coordinates.
- Mention that the image of the Moon is only a representation of what
it would actually look like in the sky...similarly for planets.
- Also mention that just because stars appear in the sky at some point,
that doesn't mean you can see them. For example, in the startup screen
after you've set up the demo, you'll see a bunch of stars around
the Sun. That's what the sky would look like if the Sun weren't
there.
- Call up the Ecliptic Coordinate Line, and explain to the class what it is.
Keep this up throughout the demo and point out how the planets and the
Moon all seem to remain near it.
- Disable locking and run time forward in steps of 2 minutes looking West
in Local Horizon mode so that they can see how the sky looks at sunset.
Afterwards, reenable locking and return to the starting time and Star
Atlas coordinate system.
- Run the time steps forward (maybe in one or two hour time steps if you
find it is going to quickly for six hour steps) and show how the
Moon moves.
- Stop at certain points along the way to show when the Moon gets to the
interesting points described in the assignment and verify everything,
including the data in the table. If there is time, show what it looks
like using the Local Horizon coordinate system.
- Verify angular separations by clicking on the Moon, double clicking on
the Sun icon (in the planets bar...this centers on the Sun automatically
rather than forcing you to find it), then clicking on the Sun, then
typing Cmd-A. All the other information in the table can be gotten
from the data cards that appear when you click the objects.
Post-assignment demonstration
- Set up Voyager the same way you did before. Remind everyone what they
are looking at, especially with the Ecliptic line. Do the following:
- Hide stars. They just get in the way for this demonstration.
- Change the view with ``Observe From Point...'' Go to Heliocentric
Latitude of 90 degrees and a distance of 2.5 AU from the Sun.
- Double click on the Sun on the planets bar to center on the Sun.
You should see the symbols for the inner four planets on the screen.
- Enable the trails option, lock to the Sun, and set the time step to
be two days. Set it into motion. This is so that students can
see planetary motion from a ``God's Eye'' perspective. The idea
here is to get the students oriented in space, so they'll know where
they are and what they are seeing.
- Change the Moon to a disk image, increase the magnification levels
to their respective maximums (1000x for disk magnification, 100x for
the Earth-Moon distance magnification). Note how incredibly
oversized the Moon is in this image, and then let it go forward.
The trails will display the Moon's path...note to the students how
it is orbiting the Earth and always has the side facing the Sun lit.
- Stop at some point in the simulation and ask the students what they
think the phase of the Moon is just from looking at the image from
their perspective. Use ``Return to Earth'' to check by double clicking
on the Moon icon and clicking on the Moon to check its data card.
Do this a couple of times at different phases (like first vs third
quarter) until most of them have it down.
- Use this demo to refute the ``Harvard Hypothesis''
- Observe from 90 degrees heliocentric latitude and 10 AU away from
the Sun. Center on the Earth. Change the Moon disk magnification
to 100x, and the Earth-Moon distance magnification to 100x. Zoom in all
the way and then out one step...this should be a perfect scale. Now turn
on the trails option and set the time step to 12 hours. Lock on the
Earth and let it go forward. This should draw out the orbit of
the Moon. We're supposed to see here that it looks elliptical,
but it looks quite circular on first inspection. A closer look, though,
will reveal the slight ellipticity, and students will pick this up.
Ask them to guess where the Moon's angular size will be the smallest,
then ``Return to Earth'' to check.
- Observe from a point that is 90 degrees in heliocentric longitude away
from where you are and 1.5 AU away from the Sun (don't change the
heliocentric latitude). Center and lock on the Earth. Make the Moon's
image a disk with 100x magnification (so it's easy to see where the Moon
is, but the Moon doesn't overpower the image). Turn off the inner
planets except for the Earth and Moon. Now run it forward in time
steps of 12 hours. NOTE: The ecliptic line now represent the
orbital plane of the Earth. Explain this to them, noting that you
are now looking at the Earth as if you were on Mars, observing it
in ``quadrature''. A top view diagram on the board might help.
What you should see after a little bit is that the orbit of the Moon
is tilted slightly out of the plane of the ecliptic. Be sure
everyone understands what they are looking at. Use this to answer
the question on why eclipses don't happen every two weeks.
- Go out to a distance of 50 AU, lock on the Sun, enable trails, set
the time step to 4 years, erase the line of the ecliptic, and let
it go forward. This should show the definition of the plane of
the solar system. You can then describe how the Moon's orbit is
close to this plane, and so how, from our perspective, everything
in the sky, including the Moon, always lies close to this plane
in the sky. Be patient while explaining this one...it is difficult!
- If you have time, get into a discussion of correlation vs causation
on the issue of the Moon's angular size and phase. Be creative on
this one, and the discussion can be very helpful. It gives students
a good idea with a very simple example of how science is done.
Return to the Astronomical Teaching Archives page.